Wednesday, 25 June 2014

Insurance Agents Can't Compete Against Former Brokerage







In Renfrew Insurance Ltd. v. Cortese, the Alberta Court of Appeal upheld an interlocutory injunction that prevented two insurance agents from soliciting customers and employees from their former employer.


Enforceability of Non-Competition Agreements


In cases in which an employer asks the court to stop a former employee from competing, the key issue is usually the legal validity of the non-compete clause in the employment contract.  Since a non-compete clause restrains trade and can prevent the former employee from earning a living, courts often declare them unenforceable on public policy grounds.


The law does recognize that there are circumstances, however, in which a non-competition agreement is needed to protect the employer's interests, such as when the employee has gained access to trade secrets and developed relationships with long-term customers in the course of employment.  Seeking to strike a balance between the interests of the employee and the employer, the courts scrutinize non-competition clauses carefully, upholding them only when they are reasonably necessary to protect the employer's legitimate business interests.




This analysis normally focusses on the geographic and temporal scope of the non-compete.  If the clause would prevent the employee from working in areas where he was not engaged by the employer, or seeks to keep the employee out of the market for a lengthy period of time, it can be struck down.






In the Renfrew Insurance case, insurance agents Cortese and Reed each signed a Unanimous Shareholder Agreement (the "USA") in order to become part owners in the broker, Renfrew.  The USA contained a restrictive covenant that prevented them from competing in the insurance business within 60 km of Renfrew's Calgary office for 6 months after the termination of employment.  The covenant also stated that they would not solicit any of Renfrew's customers or employees for 18 months.






In January of 2014, both agents took jobs with one of Renfrew's competitors, BFL Insurance Services ("BFL").  They immediately started to work out of BFL's Calgary office, claiming however that they were servicing customers in Edmonton, Canmore, and elsewhere in Alberta and not within the 60 km radius prohibited by the covenant.  Two Renfrew customer service representatives who had previously worked with Cortes and Reed joined BFL.  Furthermore, at least two former Renfrew clients switched to BFL, although these clients were being served by another BFL agent and not by Cortese or Reed.






Test for Injunctive Relief




In order to obtain a pre-trial injunction enforcing a non-compete clause, the employer has to pass a three part test:






1.     Is there a strong case that the clause is legally valid, and that the employee is in breach?






2.     Will the employer suffer "irreparable harm", meaning losses that can't be adequately compensated by an award of monetary damages, if the employee is allowed to compete until trial?






3.     Does the balance of convenience between the employee and the employer favour the injunction?






The judge who heard the original application concluded that the covenant against competition was reasonable in scope.  In reaching this conclusion, he took note of the fact that the clause appeared in a shareholders' agreement rather than in an employment contract, so the contract was more like a commercial transaction between partners in a business than a conventional employer-employee relationship.  He also concluded that the agents were not pressured to sign the USA, that signing was not a condition for their continued employment, and that they had independent legal advice.






The application judge held that the restriction on soliciting Renfrew customers was reasonable, having regard to the importance of the "book of business" in an insurance brokerage business.  It was also significant that the two agents had built their "niche" in the business with Renfrew's assistance.






Given that two other Renfrew employees had left to join BFL, and that two customers had switched brokers, the application judge was prepared to infer that the agents were in breach and that the threat to the Renfrew business was serious enough to constitute irreparable harm.






The restrictive covenants in this case specified that damages would not be an adequate remedy, and this was another factor that favoured the injunction.






Standard of Review on Appeal




In granting or denying an interlocutory injunction, the application judge is exercising judicial discretion.  An appellate court will defer to the judge below unless he decided the case arbitrarily or applied wrong legal principles.  The interpretation of restrictive covenants is a question of law, reviewable on a standard of correctness, but where factual findings are needed in order to apply the clause, the findings of the judge should be upheld in the absence of palpable and overriding error.






In other words, in this kind of case, the Court of Appeal will uphold the decision of the application judge unless it is clearly wrong.  The Appellate Court felt that intervention was not justified, and dismissed the employees' appeal.




Renfrew Insurance Ltd. v. Cortese, 2014 ABCA 203






Contact Richard Hayles at Billington Barristers:

(403) 930-4106


Visit our website: http://billingtonbarristers.com

View my profile on LinkedIn: Richard Hayles on LinkedIn


Any legal information provided is general in nature and may not apply to particular situations. It does not constitute legal opinion or advice. Please consult your lawyer regarding your specific legal issue.




35 comments:

  1. Hi awesome pot and share great information here. i like your blog.

    Mortgage brokers in Calgary

    ReplyDelete
  2. I didn't know there was this much into what could cause trouble. It was good to read up on it. It will help me out next time I need to talk to a broker.

    Alena | http://www.allianceins-mtg.com/

    ReplyDelete
  3. I've heard from a few different sources that going into the insurance field and becoming an insurance broker is brilliant idea. I hear that they don't just make decent money, but their benefits are unreal. It got me curious to learn more, and this gave me some great insights.

    http://www.allianceins-mtg.com/

    ReplyDelete
  4. This is just common sense. In any business, insurance or not, a employee who creates their own business can't solicit old clients. I'm glad we have a law in place, but I don't think most people need it. For something as ubiquitous as insurance, there are always more clients out there.

    Jenn | http://www.argeneral.com.au

    ReplyDelete
  5. This all seems to be common sense to me. I actually need to talk to a broker, but I'm not at all sure what to look for. Do you have any advice?

    https://donovaninsurance.com/personal_ins.htm

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have been looking into a new insurance company. I hope I can find an insurance company that works well with my home. I cannot wait to get an insurance company that works well with my home. http://www.macdowellins.com/

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm glad I've always had good employers. So many insurance problems stem from problems at work. I've been lucky so far to avoid any legal trouble, but that doesn't mean I don't need my insurance. I think it's even more important to maintain my track record. http://www.mcburneysinsurance.ca/en/

    ReplyDelete
  8. A friend of mine suggested that I look into the insurance field for a career. This is something that I've never given any thought to, and figured that it would be worth looking into. This helped me understand insurance brokers do and its something that I would love to learn more about.

    http://www.jefferyandspence.com/about_us/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Seeking to strike a balance between the interests of the employee and the employer, the courts scrutinize non-competition clauses carefully, upholding them only when they are reasonably necessary to protect the employer's legitimate business interests.
    commercial insurance agencies

    ReplyDelete
  10. crazyly insightful article. If only it was as easy to implement some of the solutions as it was to read and nod my head at each of your points agency software

    ReplyDelete
  11. It's too good,.i really like it,
    "forex"

    ReplyDelete
  12. Our insurance broking management software is one of the most convenient ways to calculate the exact premium amount of different types of polices. There are number of insurance companies use SAIBA software on extensive basis.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Buying private health insurance, broker or direct?
    insurance broker

    ReplyDelete
  14. An excellent site for a long time I am following the site almost every day, but I added your site or landing pages get into the commonly used rate slowed down in recent days I wonder if they have a problem with my computer is also unclear to me. Nevertheless, this site would like to thank those who contributed. Cheap life insurance in Houston

    ReplyDelete
  15. it's a nice blog about the trading concepts,.
    forex exchange trading

    ReplyDelete
  16. I wanted to thank you for this great read. Your blog is one of the finest blog . Thanks for posting this informative article.
    towing service

    ReplyDelete
  17. Thank you for the helpful post. I found your blog with Google and I will start following. Hope to see new blogs soon.
    miami boat insurance

    ReplyDelete
  18. It's a nice and informative post about trading,
    trading reviews

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks for sharing info. Keep up the good work...We hope you will visit our blog often as we discuss topics of interest to you
    TRUCK TOWING

    ReplyDelete
  20. You have given the very useful information with the help of this blog. Software For Health Insurance is very important tool for agencies and brokers.

    ReplyDelete
  21. There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration.
    T Dog Towing Augusta

    ReplyDelete
  22. Great article nicely presented and informative article.
    heavy haul transportation

    ReplyDelete
  23. The blog article very surprised to me! Your writing is good. In this I learned a lot! Thank you!
    heavy haul transportation

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thanks for sharing this really an amazing and nice post,
    binary options success stories

    ReplyDelete
  25. That's really helpful blog and i have learned so many thing from here,.
    Platinum Seminar Sweden

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thanks, very helpful.

    You can also check the exclusive commercial Real estate property in Calgary, Click here calgaryofficespace.ca. We offer a full suite of services including office space, commercial property, and Office space for rent Calgary & Shared Office Space Calgary at the reasonable price.

    ReplyDelete
  27. 9 Reasons Abraham Lincoln Would Be Great At Forex Duality - https://www.reviewengin.com/forex-duality-review/

    ReplyDelete
  28. What Is Forex Trading? Find Out Here!

    A Forex Duality Review By Tradeology is something that a lot of Forex Traders are waiting for these days. Commercial and investment banks can be considered as the foundation of the forex markets; they are the liquidity providers. Nicola Delic will explain the different indicators and what makes them so important. There is always something that can impact the FX markets more than macroeconomic indicators, press conferences of central banks, or speeches by their governors. This includes trading hours, trade entries, trade exits, stop loss and take profit levels, indicators to use, as well as how to deal with economic news releases.

    TD Ameritrade is the only other firm that can beat the $2.00 minimum, by charging a $1.00 minimum on all foreign currency trades. Moreover, members will not just pick up how to accurately use ND10X, but they will also learn how the forex market works and how forex trading takes place. Choosing a lot size too big or opening more trades than your margin can support will be the death of most forex accounts. Tradeology trade marauder reviewit spares your chance profitably as you get alarms either in letterbox or various inbox.

    A swap is a daily charge or withdrawal from the deposit of a trader of money for the transfer of a position on open trades over the night. The core of the FX Market Code combines the power of momentum with crystal-clear trade entry signals that could result in you making even more money than you ever have trading. The staff at is here to help you achieve these goals, especially from a knowledge perspective, but determining if a trading regimen is right for you will come from hours of practice trading with virtual” cash and real time quotes on a free demo” account.

    When you buy into the system, you get this first of its kind Smart Trading Technology that makes it easier to trade these markets. Additionally, forex mini accounts give investors the same access to various forex tools, including trading platforms, charts, and more. That's the definition of what a forex trading strategy is. With all those strategies at my disposal, I think I could trade at all types of market (trending or ranging) and at high and low time frames and approach it at different angles. ND10X - a line of ClickBank products, does not give many details about its capabilities. https://www.reviewengin.com/tips-to-write-eye-catching-headline-for-blog/

    ReplyDelete
  29. Nice post shared. Get legal assistance of all kinds from Dimic Law's experienced lawyers in Calgary.

    ReplyDelete